VENEZUELA AND TRUMPIST CAUDILLISMO AS FOREIGN POLICY

 

The popular saying, “God gives bread to those who have no teeth,” is commonly used to describe situations in which resources, opportunities, or economic and political power end up in the hands of those who neither deserve them nor use them fairly. This is precisely what happened in Venezuela, where the fall of Nicolás Maduro exposed a deeply troubling conspiracy: the current president, Delcy Rodríguez, negotiated with Washington at a very early stage, probably as far back as January 22, 2026, the violent extraction of the president by a U.S. commando unit.

The British newspaper, The Guardian, citing confidential sources, reported that prominent figures within the Chavista regime had communicated to American and Qatari officials their willingness to accept Maduro’s removal. This information fueled suspicions that prior understandings may have existed, although it does not establish as a judicially proven fact every account of an alleged personal betrayal.

The political question, however, goes beyond determining who conspired against whom in the corridors of the Miraflores Palace in Caracas. The contradiction is plain to see: those who had served in Maduro’s government could also become interlocutors for Washington, while the promise of democratic transformation was entirely sidelined in negotiations among political elites. What, then, does Venezuela's transition actually consist of? Replacing Maduro without dismantling the dictatorial system that allowed him to govern authoritarianly? Negotiating the opening of the oil industry while leaving intact the structures capable of intimidating society? Accepting a new relationship with the United States without guaranteeing that citizens can freely choose their own rulers?

The report published by the British House of Commons Library on September 24, 2026, records partial progress in the release of prisoners and changes in diplomatic relations between Washington and Caracas. However, it also warns that hundreds of political prisoners remain in detention, according to records cited by human rights organizations, alongside restrictions on freedom of expression and the continued presence in important positions of officials previously identified as responsible for serious human rights violations. The same report notes that the United States made the holding of free elections conditional upon institutional and political guarantees that have yet to materialize, because Trump prioritized oil and direct business deals between privileged Venezuelan entrepreneurs and powerful American investors.

The continuity of Chavismo is the real problem in Venezuela. It is not necessarily Rodríguez’s individual betrayal of the former dictator Maduro, but rather the possibility that the democratic aspirations of millions of citizens were sacrificed to guarantee the survival of a segment of the old regime.

Venezuelans are not simply demanding a change in the occupant of the Miraflores Palace. They are demanding the restoration of their right to decide, the reconstruction of their institutions, and an end to impunity. If those responsible for repression remain protected by political agreements, Maduro’s capture will have changed the pinnacle of power without resolving the fundamental problem of justice and the democratic reconstruction of the entire political system.

The second paradox lies in Washington. Donald Trump has turned American foreign policy into an extension of his own caudillista leadership: decisions concentrated in the hands of the president, displays of force, unproductive negotiations, and a preference for agreements that can be presented as immediate victories.

There is no need to argue that Trumpism is identical to historical fascism to recognize troubling similarities in its relationship with power. Contempt for certain institutional constraints, the glorification of the leader's personal will, exclusionary and racist nationalist rhetoric, and the tendency to portray politics as a confrontation between friends and enemies all point to authoritarian and fascistic traits. The ideological denigration that Trump became accustomed to practicing quickly evolved into a permanent effort to destroy the traditional institutions designed to hold power accountable.

The parallel with Chavismo is equally uncomfortable, precisely because both political projects—that of Trump and that of Hugo Chávez—despite their ideological differences and the enormous asymmetry of power between their respective countries, have privileged the concentration of leadership and the subordination of constitutional principles to political survival, at any cost.

Maduro invoked national sovereignty to defend a system that had drastically reduced the possibilities for democratic alternation in power. Trump invokes American national security and national interests to justify a foreign policy in which military force and control over strategic resources acquire decisive importance. One used revolutionary nationalism to protect his regime; the other uses American nationalism to expand the scope of action of an authoritarian government.

The Venezuelan outcome reveals just how far this convergence can go: Trump, as Maduro’s declared adversary, ultimately negotiated with one of the most important figures in Maduro’s own government, Delcy Rodríguez, abruptly erasing the entire history of dictatorship and the rhetoric of legitimate liberation in the name of democracy.

A report by one of the most important British organizations dedicated to the study of international relations, Chatham House, indicates that Maduro’s capture raised questions as early as January 2026 about the consequences of the intervention for the international order, viewing the American decision to assume a direct role in governing Venezuela as deeply troubling. This is not merely a debate about the legitimacy of Chavismo, but about whether a major power can impose its political objectives through force without establishing dangerous precedents for other states or fostering a genuine transition to democracy. Trumpist personalism is, at its core, a failed foreign policy.

The capture of Maduro, who faces accusations of serious crimes such as drug trafficking and transnational criminal organization, does not automatically grant a foreign power the right to determine the destiny of an entire country. Nor does the disputed legitimacy of Maduro eliminate the international obligations of the United States. If the defense of democracy depends on the unilateral will of a foreign president, it ceases to be a universal principle and becomes an instrument of power. Trump has not only shattered international law in order to imprison Maduro; he now also arrogates to himself the freedom to support—or withhold support from—democratization according to his own whims and preferences. This is an abuse far more dramatic than the invasion of Panama carried out by the United States in 1989.



Comentarios